Guide for everyone

APA vs MLA vs Chicago: which one to use

APA, MLA and Chicago were built by different professions to answer different questions about a source. Find the question and the choice becomes quick.

Citation styles are not three ways of doing the same thing. Each one was built by a different profession to answer a different question about a source. Once you see the question, the rules stop looking arbitrary, and choosing between APA, MLA and Chicago becomes quick.

First check whether the choice is yours

Usually it is not. Read, in this order:

  1. The assignment sheet or the journal's author guidelines. If a style is named, use it and stop reading this section.
  2. The course syllabus or the department's style page. Many departments pick one style for every course.
  3. Your field. If nobody has said anything, the table below gives the usual default.

If after all three you still have a free choice, pick the style your readers see most often. A history professor reads Chicago footnotes without effort and finds APA brackets distracting. A psychology instructor feels the opposite.

The question each style is built to answer

APA: how recent is this?

APA comes from the social sciences, where a finding from 2009 may have been overturned by 2019. So the year sits right after the author's name, in the text and in the reference list: (Tosk & Brennholt, 2021). The reader judges the age of the evidence without looking anything up. The current edition is the 7th (2019).

MLA: where exactly in the text?

MLA comes from literature and language study, where the argument lives in close reading. The year matters less than the page, so the in-text citation is author and page with nothing between them: (Tosk and Brennholt 41). The current edition is the 9th (2021).

Chicago: keep the page clean, or keep the date close

Chicago offers two systems. Notes-bibliography puts a superscript number in the text and the source in a footnote or endnote, so the prose stays uncluttered and the writer can add commentary in the note. History, art history, religion, music and most book publishing use it. Author-date works like APA, with (Tosk and Brennholt 2021, 41) in the text. Some sciences and social sciences that publish in Chicago-styled journals use it. When someone says "use Chicago" and nothing more, they almost always mean notes-bibliography; ask if it matters.

Who uses what

StyleTypical fieldsName of the list
APA 7thPsychology, education, nursing, social work, business, many sciencesReferences
MLA 9thLiterature, languages, composition courses, film, cultural studiesWorks Cited
Chicago notes-bibliographyHistory, art history, philosophy, religion, publishingBibliography
Chicago author-dateSome natural and social sciencesReferences

These are tendencies, not laws. An engineering course may ask for IEEE, and a business school may ask for Chicago. The assignment sheet wins.

One article, written four ways

The source below is invented for this guide. The authors, the journal and the DOI do not exist. Watch three things as you read: what is in italics, where the year sits, and how the page range is written.

APA 7th reference list
Tosk, M., & Brennholt, J. (2021). Night classes and the returning student: Attendance patterns in two cities. Review of Evening Study, 14(2), 38–55. https://doi.org/10.0000/res.2021.1402
In the text: (Tosk & Brennholt, 2021, p. 41) or Tosk and Brennholt (2021) found that…

MLA 9th works cited
Tosk, Mirela, and Jonas Brennholt. "Night Classes and the Returning Student: Attendance Patterns in Two Cities." Review of Evening Study, vol. 14, no. 2, 2021, pp. 38-55. https://doi.org/10.0000/res.2021.1402.
In the text: (Tosk and Brennholt 41)

Chicago notes-bibliography
Note: 1. Mirela Tosk and Jonas Brennholt, "Night Classes and the Returning Student: Attendance Patterns in Two Cities," Review of Evening Study 14, no. 2 (2021): 41, https://doi.org/10.0000/res.2021.1402.
Bibliography: Tosk, Mirela, and Jonas Brennholt. "Night Classes and the Returning Student: Attendance Patterns in Two Cities." Review of Evening Study 14, no. 2 (2021): 38–55. https://doi.org/10.0000/res.2021.1402.

Chicago author-date
Tosk, Mirela, and Jonas Brennholt. 2021. "Night Classes and the Returning Student: Attendance Patterns in Two Cities." Review of Evening Study 14 (2): 38–55. https://doi.org/10.0000/res.2021.1402.
In the text: (Tosk and Brennholt 2021, 41)

Some details worth a second look. APA uses initials and sentence case for the article title: only the first word, the first word after the colon and proper nouns are capitalized. MLA and Chicago use full names and capitalize the main words of the title. In APA the volume number is italic along with the journal name; in MLA and Chicago it is not. APA and Chicago join the page range with an en dash (38–55); the MLA Handbook's own examples use a plain hyphen (38-55). APA ends with the DOI and no period; MLA and Chicago close the entry with one. In every style the list uses a hanging indent: the first line of each entry at the margin, the rest indented.

The rules that cost the most points

Most lost points come from a handful of thresholds that differ between styles. The table collects them.

RuleAPA 7thMLA 9thChicago
"et al." in the textThree or more authors, from the first citationThree or more authorsFour or more authors
Authors listed in the entryUp to 20; for more, first 19, an ellipsis, then the lastTwo in full; three or more as first author plus "et al."More than in the text; the exact cutoff depends on the edition, so check
Block quotation starts at40 wordsMore than four lines of prose in your paperAbout 100 words or more
Page number for a paraphraseEncouraged, not requiredRequired when the source has pagesExpected in notes and author-date citations

Two more habits save time. Keep your in-text form and your list form from the same style; mixing (Tosk and Brennholt 41) in the text with an APA list is one of the most common errors a grader sees. And decide early how you will handle sources without a date or page number, because each style has its own abbreviation for that case (APA uses n.d. for no date; MLA simply omits the element).

A writer's entry, and the fix

A fictional student, Benedikt, is writing for a literature course that asked for MLA. He has used APA for two years as a psychology major, and his first works-cited entry shows it. Before you read his revision, ask: in MLA, where does the year go, how are authors' names written, and what marks the article title?

Before Tosk, M., & Brennholt, J. (2021). Night classes and the returning student: Attendance patterns in two cities. Review of Evening Study, 14(2), p. 38–55.
After Tosk, Mirela, and Jonas Brennholt. "Night Classes and the Returning Student: Attendance Patterns in Two Cities." Review of Evening Study, vol. 14, no. 2, 2021, pp. 38-55. https://doi.org/10.0000/res.2021.1402.

Benedikt's first version had the APA shape with an added mistake: "p." before a range, which no style uses. His revision moves the year after the issue, spells out the names, puts the title in quotation marks with title case, italicizes the journal, labels volume and issue, and adds the DOI he had left out. Nothing here required new information. It required checking which rule book he was in.

Chicago: picking between the two systems

If your instructor says "Chicago" and you are in history, the humanities or a writing program, use notes-bibliography. If you are in a science or social-science course and the instructor mentions "author-date" or asks for parenthetical citations, use author-date. If the instruction is just the word "Chicago" and the course sits between those worlds, a one-line email settles it faster than guessing. Do not mix the two systems in one paper.

Three things a citation generator can and cannot do

The free citation generator on this site takes the details you enter (authors, title, journal, volume, issue, year, pages, DOI) and arranges them into APA 7th, MLA 9th or a simplified Chicago entry. That saves you from memorizing punctuation. It cannot find the details for you, it cannot tell whether a page is a journal article or a blog post unless you tell it, and it cannot see that you typed the title in the wrong case. So the routine is: find the details on the source itself, enter them carefully, then read the output against one example from your style guide before you paste it in.

If you are coming back to study after years away, the mechanics of citation are often the part that feels most foreign; the guide for returning students covers how to build the habit without it eating your evenings. And a citation only answers the question "where did this come from?" Whether the words around it are properly your own is the subject of the paraphrasing guide.

A short decision path

  1. Named in the assignment or the journal's guidelines? Use that.
  2. Named in the syllabus or on the department's site? Use that.
  3. Literature, languages, composition? MLA. Social sciences, education, nursing, business? APA. History and the humanities? Chicago notes-bibliography. A science course asking for Chicago? Author-date, and confirm.
  4. Still unsure? Ask, in one sentence, before you write the first citation. Changing styles after the draft is finished takes an hour you will not enjoy.

Try it on your own draft

Paste a paragraph and see what the fox marks. The rewriting stays with you.

Open Citation generator