Guide for ESL

Run-on sentences and comma splices, explained for ESL writers

A comma splice and a run-on sentence are the same error with different punctuation: two complete sentences and a joint too weak to hold them. Here is how to see the seam and the four ways to fix it.

Two complete sentences sit next to each other. If only a comma holds them together, the result is a comma splice. If nothing holds them together, it is a run-on, which grammar books also call a fused sentence. Readers rarely know the names, but they feel the bump: the sentence keeps going after the point where their mind expected it to stop. Instructors mark both errors heavily because they look like carelessness even when the writer was being careful. Both have the same cause and the same four fixes.

The term you need: independent clause

An independent clause is a group of words with a subject and a verb that could stand alone as a sentence. The clinic opens at seven is one. Because the clinic opens at seven is not, since because turns it into a fragment, an incomplete sentence that waits for the rest of the thought. A dependent clause is that second kind: it has a subject and a verb, but a word at its front makes it lean on another clause.

Every comma splice and every run-on is two independent clauses with the wrong joint between them. Once you can spot an independent clause, you can spot the error.

The finger test

Put a finger over a comma in your draft. Read the words before the finger. Could they end with a period and make sense? Now read the words after it. Could they begin with a capital letter and stand alone? If both answers are yes, the comma is doing a job it cannot do, and you have a splice. For run-ons there is no comma to cover, so read the sentence aloud and listen for the place where your voice drops as if a sentence had ended. Cover that spot and run the same test.

The writers in the examples below are invented. The errors are the ones instructors see most, and every example uses American English.

BeforeThe clinic opens at seven, the parking lot is full by six thirty.
AfterThe clinic opens at seven, but the parking lot is full by six thirty.

Rule: a comma alone cannot join two independent clauses. Both halves pass the finger test, so they need a stronger joint. Here the writer chose a comma plus but, which also tells the reader the two facts are in tension.

BeforeI finished the shift report my supervisor had already gone home.
AfterI finished the shift report. My supervisor had already gone home.

Rule: two independent clauses with no punctuation between them form a run-on. A period is the simplest fix and often the best one. Nobody loses points for a short sentence.

The four fixes, and what each one means

Take one spliced sentence and repair it four ways. Each repair is grammatical, and each says something slightly different about how the two ideas relate.

Original: The bus was late, I missed the first ten minutes of class.

  1. Period. The bus was late. I missed the first ten minutes of class. Two facts, side by side. The reader supplies the connection.
  2. Semicolon. The bus was late; I missed the first ten minutes of class. The semicolon says the two facts belong together more closely than a period would suggest. Use it when both halves carry equal weight.
  3. Comma plus a coordinating conjunction. The bus was late, so I missed the first ten minutes of class. English has seven coordinating conjunctions, the joining words that connect equal parts: for, and, nor, but, or, yet, so. Many students remember them as FANBOYS. The comma goes before the conjunction, never after it.
  4. Subordinator. Because the bus was late, I missed the first ten minutes of class. A subordinator is a word such as because, although, when, after, before, if, since, until or while. It turns one clause into a dependent clause, so the sentence now has only one independent clause and no splice. When the dependent clause comes first, put a comma after it. When it comes second, you usually need no comma: I missed the first ten minutes of class because the bus was late.

Notice that the fourth version is the only one that states the cause outright. Choosing a fix is choosing a meaning, which is why a mechanical habit of replacing every comma splice with a semicolon produces stiff writing.

Three traps that look like fixes

Trap 1: however, therefore, then

These words feel like conjunctions, and in many languages their equivalents are. In English they are adverbs, words that modify a verb or comment on a whole sentence. An adverb cannot join two independent clauses, so a comma before however leaves the splice in place.

BeforeI wanted to apply for the spring semester, however, the deadline had passed.
AfterI wanted to apply for the spring semester; however, the deadline had passed.

Rule: when however, therefore, moreover, otherwise, consequently or nevertheless sits between two independent clauses, put a semicolon before it and a comma after it. A period before it works just as well: The deadline, however, had passed. The word then follows the same rule. She clocked out, then she drove to class is a splice; She clocked out and then drove to class is not, because the second half has no subject of its own and is therefore not an independent clause. The guide to linking words covers these words in more depth.

Trap 2: the pronoun that starts the second half

Splices cluster around pronouns. When the second clause begins with he, she, it, they, this or that, the writer feels the two halves are about the same thing and reaches for a comma.

BeforeMy manager approved the schedule change, she signed the form the same day.
AfterMy manager approved the schedule change and signed the form the same day.

Rule: a shared subject does not permit a comma splice. Either keep two clauses and join them properly, or do what the revision does: drop the second subject and let one subject carry two verbs. No comma is needed between two verbs that share a subject.

Trap 3: the comma that follows a long introduction

BeforeAfter three years on the night shift and two semesters of prerequisites at the community college, I was accepted into the nursing program, my family celebrated for a week.
AfterAfter three years on the night shift and two semesters of prerequisites at the community college, I was accepted into the nursing program. My family celebrated for a week.

Rule: a long opening phrase needs a comma after it, and that correct comma can make the next comma feel natural too. Test every comma separately. The first one here separates an introductory phrase from the main clause and is right. The second joins two independent clauses and is wrong.

Length is not the problem

A run-on is a sentence with a broken joint, and a five-word sentence can have one: It rained, we stayed home. A forty-word sentence with every clause properly joined is grammatical, though it may exhaust the reader for other reasons. Keep the two problems separate in your mind. Fix joints with the four tools above. Fix length by cutting words or splitting ideas, which is a different task and the subject of the guide on removing filler words.

Why careful writers make this error

In a number of languages, a comma between two complete sentences is normal in formal writing, and good writers use it on purpose. If you learned to write in one of those languages, the English rule can feel fussy. It is a convention. It says nothing about the quality of your English. The second cause is sound. Writers hear a pause and write a comma, because a teacher once told them a comma marks a pause. English punctuation marks grammar first and breath second, so a pause between two complete sentences gets a period or a semicolon, however short the pause.

When a comma splice is allowed

Fiction writers and advertisers splice short, parallel clauses on purpose: I came, I saw, I conquered. The effect is speed. In an essay, a personal statement, a cover letter or an email to a supervisor, the risk is too high. A reader who is grading or hiring will see an error before a style choice. Save the device for a text to a friend.

Finding them in your own draft

  1. Read the draft backward, last sentence first. This breaks the flow of meaning so that each sentence stands alone, and splices become visible.
  2. Use your word processor's search for , however, , therefore, , then and , so. Check each hit with the finger test. (, so is correct when so joins two clauses; it is the one FANBOYS word writers often doubt.)
  3. Look at every comma that is followed by he, she, it, they, this, that, we or I. Most splices start there.
  4. Count the subject-verb pairs in any sentence longer than two lines. Two pairs with no conjunction or subordinator between them means a repair is due.

A clarity checker cannot identify a comma splice for you; it flags sentences over 30 words, and a flagged sentence is a good place to run the finger test, since long sentences are where splices hide. Related comma rules, including when a comma is and is not needed with and, are covered in American punctuation basics.

Try it on your own draft

Paste a paragraph and see what the fox marks. The rewriting stays with you.

Open Clarity checker