Guide for ESL

Linking words: however, therefore, although and how to punctuate them

Meaning does not decide how to punctuate a linking word; its grammar family does. Three families, one table and six common errors fixed.

The usual list of linking words is sorted by meaning: words for contrast, words for cause, words for addition. That list is why so many essays contain the error the course is online, however, the exams are in person. Meaning does not decide the punctuation. Grammar does, and English linking words belong to three grammatical families with three different sets of rules. Learn the families once and the commas and semicolons take care of themselves.

Three families

Each family can express contrast, cause, or addition. What differs is what the word does to the sentence.

Family 1: coordinating conjunctions

Seven words: for, and, nor, but, or, yet, so. They join two complete sentences, which grammar books call independent clauses, into one. Put a comma before the conjunction when a complete sentence follows it.

The course is online, but the exams are in person.

Family 2: subordinators

Words such as although, though, even though, because, since, while, whereas, if, unless, when, after, before, until. A subordinator attaches to one clause and makes it dependent, meaning it can no longer stand alone. The sentence then has one main clause and one dependent clause. If the dependent clause comes first, put a comma after it. If it comes second, you usually need no comma, with one common exception: clauses of contrast (although, whereas, while meaning although) often take a comma even in second position, because the contrast is a separate thought.

Although the course is online, the exams are in person.
The exams are in person, although the course is online.
She passed because she studied every night.

Family 3: conjunctive adverbs and transition phrases

However, therefore, moreover, furthermore, nevertheless, consequently, otherwise, meanwhile, instead, then, and phrases such as in addition, as a result, for example, on the other hand, in contrast. These words carry meaning between sentences, but grammatically they are adverbs, words that comment on a verb or a whole statement. An adverb cannot join two complete sentences. Between two complete sentences, a family 3 word needs a semicolon before it and a comma after it, or a period before it. Because it is an adverb, it can also move inside the second sentence, set off by commas.

The course is online; however, the exams are in person.
The course is online. However, the exams are in person.
The course is online. The exams, however, are in person.

The same meanings, three ways

MeaningWords by family
Contrast1: but, yet
2: although, even though, whereas
3: however, nevertheless, on the other hand
Cause and result1: so, for
2: because, since, as
3: therefore, consequently, as a result
Addition1: and
2: (none)
3: moreover, furthermore, in addition, also
Example1: (none)
2: (none)
3: for example, for instance

Family 1 takes a comma before it. Family 2 makes its clause dependent, with a comma after that clause when it comes first. Family 3 takes a semicolon or a period before it and a comma after it. Keep the table nearby for a month. Before you write a linking word, ask which family it is in, and the punctuation follows. The writers in the pairs below are invented; the errors are the common ones.

Six fixes, with the rule behind each

1. A comma before however

BeforeThe program accepts transfer credits, however, the nursing courses must be retaken.
AfterThe program accepts transfer credits; however, the nursing courses must be retaken.

Rule: however is family 3. A comma before it leaves two complete sentences joined by a comma, which is a comma splice. The semicolon fixes it. So does a period, and so does moving however inside: The nursing courses, however, must be retaken. One more point of confusion: however at the start of a sentence is grammatical and takes a comma after it. Without the comma it means "in whatever way": However you count the credits, the total is short.

2. Therefore with no punctuation at all

BeforeThe budget was cut therefore we postponed the hire.
AfterThe budget was cut; therefore, we postponed the hire.

Rule: same family, same fix. In an email, the family 1 version is lighter and usually better: The budget was cut, so we postponed the hire. Therefore belongs in writing where the logic is the point, such as an argument in an essay.

3. Although paired with but

BeforeAlthough the shift was twelve hours, but nobody complained.
AfterAlthough the shift was twelve hours, nobody complained.

Rule: one contrast word per pair of clauses. Although (family 2) already makes the first clause dependent; adding but (family 1) leaves the sentence with no independent clause at all. Several widely spoken languages pair their equivalents of although and but as a matter of course, so this habit is easy to carry over. Either word alone is correct: The shift was twelve hours, but nobody complained. The same rule removes because ... so: Because the bus was late, so I missed class needs one or the other.

4. Despite followed by a full clause

BeforeDespite she had worked a double shift, she stayed for the staff meeting.
AfterAlthough she had worked a double shift, she stayed for the staff meeting.

Rule: despite and in spite of are prepositions, the small words that attach a noun to the rest of a sentence. They take a noun or an -ing form, never a clause with its own subject and verb: Despite a double shift, she stayed. Despite working a double shift, she stayed. When the next words are a full clause, switch to although or even though. Despite the fact that is grammatical and wordy; although says the same in one word.

5. A linking word on every sentence

BeforeFirstly, adult students have less time. Moreover, they have jobs. Furthermore, many have children. However, they are motivated. Therefore, colleges should offer evening classes. In conclusion, evening classes help adult students.
AfterAdult students have less time than students who enroll at eighteen. Most hold jobs, and many are raising children, so a class that meets at 10 a.m. is a class they cannot take. They are also among the most motivated students a college has. Evening sections turn that motivation into completed degrees.

Rule: a linking word labels a relationship that must already exist between the sentences. When the sentences are arranged in a logical order, most labels become unnecessary. The revision keeps two (so, also) and lets the order do the rest. The public IELTS band descriptors mark down linking words that are used mechanically, and American instructors react the same way to a paragraph that opens every sentence with Moreover. Aim for one visible linking word per three or four sentences, and vary the family.

6. While when you mean although

BeforeWhile the manager was on vacation, the team met every target.
AfterAlthough the manager was on vacation, the team met every target.

Rule: while has two meanings, "during the time that" and "although," and in the first sentence a reader cannot tell whether the writer is praising the team for coping without the manager or simply giving a date. When you mean contrast, although removes the doubt. When you mean time, during does: During the manager's vacation, the team met every target. For a side-by-side comparison of two things, whereas is the precise word: The day shift is fully staffed, whereas the night shift has two openings.

Where each family sounds right

Family 1 words are the everyday ones and fit email, chat, and spoken English. Family 2 words are the workhorses of essays, because they state the logical relationship inside a single sentence, which is what argument requires. Family 3 words are the most formal and the easiest to overuse. In a personal statement or a scholarship essay, a however or two is fine; a moreover usually signals that the writer is filling space. One habit that helps: when you reach for however, try but at the start of the sentence instead. Beginning a sentence with But or And is accepted by major American style guides, and it often reads better than the heavier word.

Linking phrases that carry a fixed preposition

Many transition phrases contain a preposition that cannot change: in addition to, as a result of, in contrast to, according to, because of, due to, on the other hand, in spite of. Errors such as according with and in the other hand are among the most common in ESL essays, and spell-check passes them. Learn these phrases as whole units, the way you learned on Monday and in March. The ESL phrase fixer flags a set of common fixed-preposition errors and explains the rule behind each; it will not catch every phrase, so keep your own list of the ones that trip you.

A check for your next essay

  1. Find every however and therefore. Is there a semicolon or a period before it and a comma after?
  2. Find every although, because, and while. Is there a but or so in the same sentence that should go?
  3. Find every despite. Is it followed by a noun or an -ing form?
  4. Count the sentences that begin with a linking word. If it is more than one in three, cut some and reorder instead.

The punctuation in this guide rests on one skill: recognizing a complete sentence. If that still feels uncertain, the guide to comma splices and run-on sentences builds it step by step, and American punctuation basics covers the comma rules that apply around these words. For how linking words fit into a timed essay, see the guide to IELTS Writing Task 2 structure.

Try it on your own draft

Paste a paragraph and see what the fox marks. The rewriting stays with you.

Open ESL phrase fixer